Heat pump: Difference between revisions

From the change wiki
No edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
An electric heat pump is one way to [[heating|heat a building]]. It works a lot like [[air conditioning]] but in reverse: The hot air goes indoors; the cold air goes outdoors.
An electric '''heat pump''' is one way to [[heating|heat a building]]. It works a lot like [[air conditioning]] but in reverse: The hot air goes indoors; the cold air goes outdoors.


Heat pumps are '''more energy-efficient''' than electric heaters.{{qn}}
{{considerations}} __NOTOC__


==Research needed for this page==
==Energy efficiency==
* ''How much'' more energy-efficient can a heat pump be?
{{sum|Only in some cases}}
** How does this depend on outdoor temperature?
 
* How much energy does it typically take to ''manufacture and install'' a heat pump?
Heat pumps can be more energy-efficient than electric heaters. But this efficiency gain disappears when the outdoor temperature is cold enough.{{qn}}
* Do heat pumps involve any rare minerals or pollutant gases? To what extent is this a concern?
 
* How often (if ever) is it viable/worthwhile to repurpose an air conditioner in the winter, to help with heating?
Worse: When electricity is generated by [[fossil fuels]], electric heating has up to 3 times the carbon emissions of just burning the fossil fuels directly in a [[natural gas]] furnace {{p2|[see why]|Most coal or natural gas power plants are only 33% efficient. They work by boiling water and driving a turbine.{{minor|Exception: Newer "combined cycle" natural gas power plants can get up to 60% efficient. But for heating homes, that's still less efficient than burning the natural gas at home.<br /><br />Also note: Electricity has losses in transmission too (power lines) - typically about 5%.}} }}. Heat pumps are almost never efficient enough to make up for this.
 
Maybe it's worth getting a heat pump if you live in an area where winters are moderate and electricity is generated mostly by renewables or nuclear.<sup>[WORLD MAP needed]</sup>
 
<tab name="Research needed for this section">
{{minor|Can be a case study or generalized statistics}}
* Need graph: Heat pump efficiency vs outdoor temperature.
* Life cycle analysis
** How much energy does it typically take to ''manufacture and install'' a heat pump?
** How often (if ever) is it viable/worthwhile to repurpose an air conditioner in the winter, to help with heating?
*** Are there any "reversible" heat pumps that can work for both heating and cooling? {{p2|(why)|~ Manufacturing half as much stuff would certainly reduce life cycle emissions.<br /><br />~ Use cases:<br />- - ~ New construction<br />- - ~ Any time someone has to replace their air conditioner anyway<br />- - ~ Any time someone has to replace their heating system anyway, and doesn't already have an air conditoner but could use one}}
</tab>
 
==Refrigerant chemicals==
{{sum|{{qn}} }}
 
Because of how heat pumps work,<!-- TODO: add a section about how they work --> they must contain a substance known as a ''refrigerant''. Most refrigerants in use today{{en}} happen to be potent [[greenhouse gases]]. They aren't supposed to leak out into the atmosphere - but they sometimes do, if the heat pump gets old or is disposed of improperly.
 
 
''This section is incomplete. It needs:''
* Quantification
** How much of [[climate change]] is due to refrigerants?
** How much worse would it be if we all used heat pumps to heat our homes?
** How does this compare to the status quo of heating (often [[natural gas]])?
* Solutions
** Are there any alternatives - [[refrigerants]] that aren't greenhouse gases? And are there tradeoffs? {{npn}}
 
==See also==
* [[Heating]]
* [[Map of electricity by source]]
 
<!-- TALK: rename this page to "heating with heat pumps"? -->

Latest revision as of 02:40, 30 August 2023

An electric heat pump is one way to heat a building. It works a lot like air conditioning but in reverse: The hot air goes indoors; the cold air goes outdoors.

Energy efficiency

Only in some cases

Heat pumps can be more energy-efficient than electric heaters. But this efficiency gain disappears when the outdoor temperature is cold enough.[QUANTIFICATION needed]

Worse: When electricity is generated by fossil fuels, electric heating has up to 3 times the carbon emissions of just burning the fossil fuels directly in a natural gas furnace [see why]Most coal or natural gas power plants are only 33% efficient. They work by boiling water and driving a turbine.Exception: Newer "combined cycle" natural gas power plants can get up to 60% efficient. But for heating homes, that's still less efficient than burning the natural gas at home.

Also note: Electricity has losses in transmission too (power lines) - typically about 5%.
. Heat pumps are almost never efficient enough to make up for this.

Maybe it's worth getting a heat pump if you live in an area where winters are moderate and electricity is generated mostly by renewables or nuclear.[WORLD MAP needed]

Can be a case study or generalized statistics

  • Need graph: Heat pump efficiency vs outdoor temperature.
  • Life cycle analysis
    • How much energy does it typically take to manufacture and install a heat pump?
    • How often (if ever) is it viable/worthwhile to repurpose an air conditioner in the winter, to help with heating?
      • Are there any "reversible" heat pumps that can work for both heating and cooling? (why)~ Manufacturing half as much stuff would certainly reduce life cycle emissions.

        ~ Use cases:
        - - ~ New construction
        - - ~ Any time someone has to replace their air conditioner anyway
        - - ~ Any time someone has to replace their heating system anyway, and doesn't already have an air conditoner but could use one

Refrigerant chemicals

[QUANTIFICATION needed]

Because of how heat pumps work, they must contain a substance known as a refrigerant. Most refrigerants in use today[ELABORATION needed] happen to be potent greenhouse gases. They aren't supposed to leak out into the atmosphere - but they sometimes do, if the heat pump gets old or is disposed of improperly.


This section is incomplete. It needs:

  • Quantification
    • How much of climate change is due to refrigerants?
    • How much worse would it be if we all used heat pumps to heat our homes?
    • How does this compare to the status quo of heating (often natural gas)?
  • Solutions
    • Are there any alternatives - refrigerants that aren't greenhouse gases? And are there tradeoffs? [new page needed]

See also